The Checkers Xpress store near St Andrews Park will close permanently on Saturday.
Owner SandpiperCI says the main reason is because many shoppers are using the nearby Morrisons Daily and Checkers Xpress at First Tower.
A spokesman adds that the 20% tax targeted at local retailers 'has made it difficult to justify keeping loss-making stores open'.
The shop is on La Route de St Aubin between First Tower and Millbrook.
The five staff will be redeployed to SandpipersCI's other nearby stores.
The news comes after First Tower residents successfully campaigned to keep their nearest Checkers Xpress store open.
Last September the competition watchdog changed its mind about forcing SandpiperCI to close the shop.

Guernsey could be disgraced Andrew’s new home - Royal biographer
Government appoints new Havre Des Pas Lido operator
Jersey Chamber of Commerce 'aghast' at recommendation to reject Strive Hotel plans
Politician calls for Havre des Pas lido tender process to be scrapped
Two Jersey rowers make Team GB
Jersey's rate of inflation rises slightly over summer
Committee calls for Deputy Philip Ozouf's suspension
Baby sloth at Jersey Zoo orphaned as mother unexpectedly dies