St Saviour Constable Kevin Lewis is to face a recount.
The Royal Court has ordered the ballot papers from last month's election be recounted after officials raised a discrepancy.
460 votes are unaccounted for - the difference between the record of the ballot cast and the total votes counted.
The results were the last to be declared on 22 June, with Kevin Lewis said to have polled 1,552 votes while 1,142 voted for none of the candidates.
That is a difference of 410, meaning there is the potential for the result of the election to change with a recount.
It will take place sometime before 20 July.
This year's election was the first to include a 'none of the candidates' option for uncontested seats.

Draft law scraps time limits on abortions in Jersey
Divide over approach to gender guidance in schools
Three charities awarded £500 grants in community campaign
Ministers back principle of social media 'restrictions' for under 16s
Passengers rerouted through Jersey Airport departures
A total ban on disposable vapes in Guernsey and Jersey is poised to take full effect
Islanders with COVID-19 symptoms reminded to avoid the hospital
2025 was the fourth warmest year on record